These Italian Clam Stuffed Mushrooms are a delicious party appetizer your guests will go crazy over! They come out crispy on top and juicy in the middle making them the perfect finger food and absolutely irresistible.
These mini portobellos are stuffed with minced clams, breadcrumbs, Italian seasoning, garlic, sherry vinegar and Parmesan cheese. What more could you want out of a stuffed mushroom?
They are perfectly seasoned and always a hit when entertaining. Finding a stuffed mushroom recipe without cream cheese is not as easy as one would think so I was on a mission to create my own. This recipe was inspired by Olive Garden’s stuffed clam mushroom appetizer. My “copycat” version is easy but still packs incredible flavor!
I love that I can make these babies ahead of time, even the night before, and then bake them as my guests arrive. So if you are looking for an easy appetizer recipe to serve a crowd, keep reading!
How to make Italian stuffed mushrooms using canned clams
Making stuffed mushrooms is not difficult to do. I think they are one of those appetizers that can look like it took you hours but in reality, they only take 40 minutes from start to finish.
The trick to the best stuffed mushrooms is to create a juicy interior while maintaining a crunchy top. The topping is the easy part. The inside is what can be tricky, especially when there is no cream cheese involved.
This is why liquids are so important in this recipe. I use a combination of the juice from the canned clams and sherry viengar to keep them moist and not dry. Nobody likes a dry stuffed mushroom.
Steps to making your stuffed mushrooms:
Step 1: Clean your mushrooms by rinsing them off quickly or by wiping them with a damp paper towel.
Step 2: Remove the stems by twisting them with your fingers. You can also use a small pairing knife.
Step 3: Scoop out the inside to create a nice sized cavity for stuffing. I like to use a small teaspoon to do this.
Step 4: Saute your onions and garlic in a skillet. Add your sherry vinegar, can of minced clams, breadcrumbs, cheese and spices.
Step 5: Allow to cool slightly and fill your mushroom cavities nice and high. You should aim for a mini mound.
Step 6: Bake for about 8 minutes. Finish by broiling the tops until golden brown. This will also make the top nice and crunchy.
What types of mushrooms are best for stuffing?
To be honest, any mini or small mushrooms that has a large enough cavity to stuff would work. With that said, some mushrooms hold up better when they are cooked while others have more of a woodsy flavor.
Here are two mushroom types that I go back and forth between when choosing which mushrooms to stuff:
- White button– These are the most mild in flavor and usually the cheapest. They hold up very well to heat and would give your stuffed mushrooms more of a ‘bite’.
- Cremini– These types are young portobellos. They are labeled as ‘baby portbellas’ or ‘baby bells’. They have more flavor than white button mushrooms and are brown in color.
Both are tasty and would work well for this recipe. Choose whichever YOU like best!
How to clean your mushrooms
Cleaning mushrooms is something I hate doing. Especially because I hear mixed reviews on how to clean them the RIGHT way. Some mushrooms I buy have SO much dirt on them, delicately wiping them with a damp paper towel just wont do.
Recently I saw a professional chef (on Food Network) talk about how they rinse mushrooms directly under water, which I thought was a huge no-no, and mentioned that it doesn’t make a difference for them. Since hearing that, I gave up on the ‘delicate’ way of cleaning them.
I have rinsed my mushrooms under cold water AND used a paper towel many times myself and never notice the difference. So lately I have simply been rinsing them under cold water quickly and immediately will pat them dry with a paper towel to remove any excess water. I just don’t have the time for wiping one by one.
With that said, YOU clean your mushrooms however YOU like to clean them. No judgement here. Just don’t soak them in water and I’m sure you, and your mushrooms, will make it out alive.
Here are some tips on how to clean them properly.
Frequently asked stuffed mushroom questions:
“How do I get a super crunchy coating”? Using panko breadcrumbs help a lot. In addition to that, make sure you add some kind of fat to your breadcrumbs like butter or oil before baking. The last step of my recipe where we broil the mushrooms is what helps “re-crunchify” them. Yes that’s a word and I’m sticking to it.
“How large do my mushrooms need to be?” Large enough to fill but small enough to eat in 1-2 bites.
“Can I make these a day ahead?” Yes! Clean, stuff and refrigerate them covered the night before if you want. Then bake them up before guests arrive!
“Can I freeze my stuffed mushrooms?” No. Mushrooms do NOT freeze well.
“How long do these stay fresh?” Your stuffed mushrooms will stay fresh in the fridge, in a sealed container, for 3-4 days.
Other appetizer recipes you may like:
Italian Clam Stuffed Mushrooms (without cream cheese)
- 10-12 small mushrooms, cremini or white button
- 3 tbsp. unsalted butter, or olive oil
- ¼ yellow onion, minced (about ¼ cup)
- 2-3 cloves garlic, minced
- 1 tbsp. sherry vinegar
- 6.5 oz. can of minced clams
- ½ tsp dried oregano
- ½ tsp dried parsley
- ½ tsp dried basil
- ¼ tsp salt ((omit if using salted butter))
- ½ cup panko breadcrumbs + 2 tbsp.
- t tbsp pecorino romano cheese
- freshly chopped parsley, for garnish
- Preheat your oven to 400°F.
- Wash your mushrooms using a damp paper towel and then set them, cavity up, on a baking sheet. Remove the stems and chop them up finely. Set them aside.
- Melt 3 oz. unsalted butter, or olive oil, in a skillet over medium-low heat and add in ¼ yellow onion minced. Saute for about 10 minutes until they become translucent.
- Turn up your heat to high and add your minced garlic cloves and saute for no more than 1 minute.
- Add your sherry vinegar, can of minced clams with juice, ½ tsp of oregano, ½ tsp of basil, ½ tsp of parsley and ⅛ tsp salt. Let simmer over high heat for 5 minutes.
- Add ½ cup of panko breadcrumbs and mix until they absorb the clam juice. Turn off heat.There should be no more liquid on the bottom of your pan. If there is, keep the heat on until all the liquid is fully absorbed/evaporated.
- When mixture is cool enough, stuff each of your mushrooms so they are nice and high. I like to use a mini ice cream scooper to get the perfectly round mound.
- Sprinkle remaining panko breadcrumbs on top of each mushroom. If they do not stick, try to flatten the top of the filling a bit to create a flatter surface.
- Bake for 8-9 minutes. If breadcrumbs are not browned yet, broil for 1-3 minutes. Garnish with fresh parsley and serve hot!